Game Theory: The Forgotten War of Minecraft (Minecraft 1.19 Update) -

Game Theory: The Forgotten War of Minecraft (Minecraft 1.19 Update)

The Game Theorists
Views: 5223220
Like: 266988
Special thanks to Squarespace for sponsoring a portion of this episode!
Start creating your website TODAY! ►
+ use code MatPat for 10% off your first website or domain!

Check out the companion episode over on FOOD THEORY! ►

With the Minecraft 1.19 update going up, I thought it was time to return to the mystery that is the sculk, the mysterious discs, and how they BOTH connect to the Warden. Today, we are focusing our eyes and ears on Disc 5. We are going way, WAY back in the history of Minecraft for this one, Theorists! Hold on to your diamond sword!

Find out more about the game here ►

Check out @Squarespace on YouTube ►

Get Your Theory Wear! ►
SUBSCRIBE to Catch all the Theories! ►

Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get A 30 Day Free Trial! ►

FNAF, The FINAL Timeline ►►
FNAF, The Monster We MISSED! ►►
FNAF This Theory Changes Everything ►
FNAF, You Were Meant To Lose ►
FNAF 6, No More Secrets ►

Writers: Matthew Patrick and Tom Robinson
Editors: Tyler Mascola and Pedro Freitas
Assistant Editor: Caitie Turner (Caiterpillart)
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman

#Minecraft #MinecraftUpdate #MinecraftWarden #MinecraftDisc #MinecraftWither #MinecraftMob #MinecraftLore #MinecraftTheory #Sculk #GameTheory #MatPat


  1. Are you going to be one about the ancient cities but they can builders the ones I got outkast build his giant city under the grounds and maybe they made this portal I don't know maybe when they made the portal somehow a boarding came out protected them I don't know maybe they just went in the pool room ordered the warden make all this

  2. One day I would like to see an update on minecrafts update notes saying "Thought you could remove me?… – H"

    And then making a new dimension called The Bane: a world full of things that just takes over things and turns them, and grows like a wild fire 🔥🦠☣️

    Who other than is running this whole new dimension?… Herobrine.. Looking to start a war with Steve after he freed his ancestors, starting a whole new chapter in Minecrafts lore… Minecrafts newest update: Minecraft: The Beginning of The End: Chapter 1…

    All leading to Herobrine being a creation of one of those 2 gods that speaks to you in the end… this one being evil and creating Herobrine: a reverse copy of Steve that started his story in another dimension who is now ready to release what he built for a decade…

    When you first go through The Bane you enter the first dimension of 3 until you battle Herobrine… And The Warden is just a foot soldier meant to protect his first dimension…

    Imagine what the devil could do with this idea 💡

  3. Knew how to make carpets but not socks… Ancient Builders are smart huh?

  4. You aren't correct about the warden killing the wither, I've tested it, however multiple wardens would probably work as an explanation

  5. this dude said the Wither was released in 2017 lol

  6. SOOOOOOOO Mojang made the warden so player will stop crying about a new world

  7. The wither was added in 1.4.2 in 2012 not 2017

  8. Plot twist: The Warden is the equivalent of a zombie in it's home dimension- a weak by comparison monster.

  9. In looking at the structures for the ancient cities, they have a lot in common with pillager outposts. I wonder if some of the builders went to the surface, and this is why they look so pale. Vindicators use those flying creatures, and those could be some kind of soul magic

  10. 15:38 doesn’t that look like the enderdragon’s head, did you guys built it there to add decoration, or did that spawn in naturally, either way I think I should shut up now.

  11. The builders just can’t get a break lmao

  12. the ancient builders weren't the ones who made it pillagers made it think about it the four towers look like pillager towers. The pillagers got kicked out by the warden because they built in his cave….(Small little theory)

  13. i think that in the new disk the roar of the warden mixed with the wither is that an farm (of something like souls) was destroyed and the player places some soulsand and makes an wither to defend himself and enters in the nether portal (thats all i could connect with)

  14. Damn they escaped one monster only to let a far worse one in.

  15. you got one thing wrong, you said that the character ran towards the surface crossing stone and dirt, this ''dirt'' makes the sound of soul sand

  16. Hey matpat idk if you knew this but the Sulk Sensor puts off red partials that fade to purple idk if this shows to you cause I use bedrock Minecraft (mobile) just wanted to let you know! If you needed to know this

  17. So we know the ancient builders could make blocks that netherite couldn't break…
    What if bedrock isn't bedrock?
    What if the builders had to stop the spread of skulk in the deep dark, so they created some kind of spell to calcify all of it?

  18. I should not have watched this video before bed.

  19. I really like the idea of this theory but if the wither is dead why wouldn’t the builders just move back to the surface?

  20. i dare you to a do a theory on train sim world 2

  21. tengo meeto☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺☺🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  22. 11:34 To me I actually think that the screeches sound more like the shriekers

  23. what if the ancient builders were the old builders from minecraft story mode

  24. I'm gonna go out on a limb and say that the story seems accurate. But the timeline doesn't. The strongholds and end dimension were clearly exploited by the builders before they encountered soul power. We know this because neither utilizes soul technology.

    The biggest support for this theory's timeline is that the new disc is called 5, placing it earlier than 11 and 13 despite them being far older and more simple

  25. Just a reminder that skulk is EXACTLY what matpat theorised soul sand to be


    me "haha wifi Redstone"

  27. I think the carpets that are used all around the city were taken from the ancient houses as they tried to flee from the warden cause we can see blue carpets in house ruins and around the city like on bridges and all

  28. If this theory does become lore, then what is terrifying is the idea that the Warden took its first ticket out, almost like it was running away from something and would much rather face the unknown in comparison to what may have been certain doom. . .

    And something that could make a Warden feel scared enough to venture out of its own domain and enter another one. . . I would rather not find out, thanks!

  29. What if the skulk originally came from the portal in the city center, and it actually connects to a corrupt dimension? Maybe this is where stuff like the zombie virus originally came from?

  30. I heard help us the thing that summons the warden

  31. Umm anyone nowdes the warden's heart thingy looks like a player if you look closely

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.